Toasted Almond Milkshake

Toasted Almond Milkshake |

This Toasted Almond Milkshake is the ultimate almond indulgence…if you loved the Good Humor man’s Toasted Almond ice cream bar you’re going to want to stick around for this…

Toasted Almond Shake, for Dad |

I’ve said it before but it bears repeating…it’s the simplest foods that give you the most pleasure…a ripe tomato picked from your own garden, the perfect cup of hot coffee just as you’re waking up, or a frosty milkshake poured, no, spooned, from your blender at the end of a long day. This recipe is in honor of my dad — it’s the first thing that popped into my mind when I was trying to think of something to post for Father’s Day. When I was growing up my dad was usually long gone for work by the time I got up. He commuted into New York City every day and while he tried to get home by dinnertime each night, that didn’t always happen. One of my most vivid memories is him standing in the kitchen late at night in his bathrobe and slippers making a thick shake with vanilla ice cream and whole milk (before cholesterol was a household word.)

Making a Toasted Almond Milkshake |

It was one of the few things I ever saw him do for himself, and I’m not sure how often he made these shakes, but in my mind it was almost every night. I bet my memory’s a little off on that one, but it was his routine for as long as I can remember, and he sure deserved it, my sisters and I had a charmed life thanks to all his hard work. Again, it was the simple things that stand out, he brought home candy in his Mad Men era briefcase every Friday night, he sat and watched The Flintstones with us on the couch, he took us to amusement parks and actually rode those Teacups, taught us how to dive under scary waves, and always had spare change for the Good Humor truck — in his suit and horn rimmed glasses he definitely had a Clark Kent vibe going on, but he’ll always be Superman to me…this one’s for you, Dad!

Toasted Almond Milkshake is the ultimate almond indulgence! |

This Toasted Almond Milkshake recipe jazzes up Dad’s plain milkshake with the flavor from his favorite ice cream bar. I inherited my love of all things almond from him, and although I haven’t had a Toasted Almond bar in decades, that flavor remains one of my favorites. This shake nails that wonderful taste. If you’re a fellow almond lover, you’re going to flip for this.

Toasting almonds for a Toasted Almond Milkshake |

The key to the flavor is all the layers of almond. I toast sliced almonds to start. You could use whole chopped almonds, or slivered. Just make sure to heat them, while stirring, until they turn fragrant and golden. I blitz the almonds with almond paste to make a crumbly mixture that is exactly like the coating on the Toasted Almond Bar. So good. I add it into the blender with the ice cream, and then, as if you weren’t already in almond heaven, I add a touch of pure almond extract. It puts it over the top.

This Toasted Almond Milkshake is a celebration of all things almond! |

My dad made his shake (he called it a “frosted”) in an old Waring blender. I still use one just like it. When it came time to re-do their kitchen, my parents had a blender built right into the counter top — that was pretty cool stuff in those days. He always used Breyer’s Vanilla ice cream, because that’s what his dad loved, and whole milk, from the milkman. Those frosteds were thick, I can still see them sliding excruciatingly slowly down the side of the blender on their way to the waiting glass. This one is worth the wait, believe me.

Happy Father’s Day dad!

A Toasted Almond Milk Shake with the flavor of the old time Good Humor Ice Cream Bar! |

more ice cream treats

Toasted Almond Milkshake |
4.50 from 20 votes

Toasted Almond Frosted

This Toasted Almond Milkshake is the ultimate almond indulgence…if you loved the Good Humor man's Toasted Almond ice cream bar you're going to want to stick around for this…
Course Dessert
Cuisine American
Yield 1 serving
Author Sue Moran


  • 4 big scoops vanilla ice cream
  • 1/2 tsp. almond extract
  • 4 Tbsp toasted almond mix plus more for garnish recipe below
  • whole milk approximately 1/2 – 1 cup

toasted almond mix

  • 1/2 cup sliced almonds
  • 1/4 stick almond paste about 2 ounces


  • To make the toasted almond mix, put the almonds in a dry skillet and toast over medium heat for several minutes, stirring constantly, until they turn fragrant and golden. Don’t let them burn! Set aside to cool
  • Cut the almond paste into chunks and put it in a food processor along with the cooled almonds and pulse until finely chopped. It should have a coarse sandy texture. You’ll have more than you need for this shake, so store the extra in the refrigerator.
  • Put the ice cream and 4 tablespoons of the toasted almond mix into the blender, followed by the extract and just enough milk to loosen it up. Blend until mixed, but don’t blend too long or the ice cream will break down.
  • Pour into a tall glass and top with more crushed almonds.

Cook’s notes

  • Milkshake, shake, frosted, frappe, floats, freezes, cabinets, malts, fribble, black cow, brown cow…what do you call them?
  • Promise me you’ll try this with Amaretto sometime.
The nutritional information for recipes on this site is provided as a courtesy and although tries to provide accurate nutritional information, these figures are only estimates.

don’t forget to pin it!

Toasted Almond Milkshake takes a page from the classic Good Humor Toasted Almond ice cream bar --- almond lovers are going to flip! |

You Might Also Like


    Leave a Reply

    Please rate this recipe!

  • Reply
    July 29, 2018 at 11:27 pm

    5 stars
    Love the story about your Dad – lovely memory to have. Absolutely love Almond in any form and this milkshake sounds wonderful. Will be made as soon as I toast the almonds. Thanks for the recipe.

  • Reply
    June 21, 2016 at 11:36 am

    5 stars
    This may just be my new ultimate favorite milkshake and I haven’t even tried! Can’t wait to make this.

  • Reply
    June 21, 2016 at 10:07 am

    i think i refer to anything made with ice cream and milk a milkshake. it’s important to note that i would use an adjective with this one, and that adjective is scrumptious. 🙂

1 2 3

Sharing is Caring

Help spread the word. You're awesome for doing it!


Get my tips, tricks & recipes for easy

foolproof baking


logo png